BLawyers Vietnam

Currently, movies based on novels, translations of books and stories are very popular. Pursuant to Vietnamese laws, such works are considered as derivative works. So what is a derivative work? How is copyright for derivative works protected? This article will provide some information on this topic.

1. What are derivative works?

The Vietnamese laws do not specifically define what is a derivative work, but only list the types of derivative works. Derivative works include works translated from one language into another, or an adapted, modified, transformed, composite, annotated or selected work.

2. Conditions for derivative works to be protected by copyright

  1. Without prejudice to the copyright to works used to create these derivative works;
  2. Making the derivative work without permission from the author or copyright owner of the work used to make such derivative work, except in case of translating the work into braille or another language for the visually impaired;
  3. Having the unique imprint of the author of the derivative work.

They must be based on the original work, do not misrepresent the author’s intentions or infringe upon the property rights and moral rights of the author who created the original work, and are not contrary to fine customs, but must still express the creation to be protected independently.

3. Copyright in derivative works

Similar to original works, the derivative works are protected from the time of creation, and are automatic rights, protected by law without registration.

The author of the derivative work has the right to publish the work and the property rights to his work.

4. Example of the dispute on intellectual property right regarding derivative work and judicial practice in Vietnam

At this article, we referred to the Judgment on Intellectual Property Right dispute No. 774/2019/DSPT dated 03 September 2019. In this case, Company PT is the organization that assigned Mr. Le Phong L to draw the illustration so that it is the owner of the work E and Mr. L is the author of the expression form of the characters O, P, Q and R drawn by himself. Company PT is the owner of the work, so it has the right to make derivative works except modify, mutilate the representation of the characters O, P, Q and R or distort these works in any way that damages the honor and reputation of Mr. L.

However, from Ho Chi Minh City Court’s viewpoint, Company PT used the expression form of characters O, P, Q and R to perform from episode 79 onwards of the E comic series as well as perform other comic series E Art, E Science, with a different form of expression than that has been registered at the Copyright Office but Company PT has not stated which activity is in the activities of adaption, modification, transform, composition, annotation or selection.

Therefore, Ho Chi Minh City Court has no basis to consider the implementation of the episodes from volume 79 onwards of the E comic series as well as the implementation of the E Art, E Science as derivative works. Company PT has violated the moral rights of author Le Phong L.

In conclusion, it can be seen that to protect the rights of derivative works and mitigate disputes with the author of the original work is to obtain permission from the author and pay royalties to be able to make the derivative products.

Should you have any questions about the above contents, please revert to BLawyers Vietnam at We are more than happy to hear from you!

Writer: Tram Nguyen

Please Login or Register for Free now to view all updates and articles

In addition to free-to-view updates and articles, you can also subscribe to the full Legal Centrix Vietnam Service including access to:

  • Overview notes on the law
  • Thousands of high quality translations of legislation covering all key business areas
  • Legal and tax updates
  • Articles on important legal and tax issues
  • Weekly email alerts
  • Sophisticated web platform and search

Legal Centrix is trusted by top law and accounting firms.

BLawyers Vietnam

BLawyers Vietnam is a law firm in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam. To be a trusted legal partner, we provide tailored and practical legal solutions to each client and cost-efficiency is always taken into consideration. Our lawyers are experienced, creative and enthusiastic legal experts. We are specializing in legal matters of investment and corporate, commerce, contracts, M&A, dispute settlement, employment, tax and real estate.

For our further information, please see at  

Click here to view the author's profile



  • Vietnam
  • Copyright
  • Legal Updates
  • General Intellectual Property

Related Content

Recent updates

Cookies On
Our Website
We use cookies on our website. To learn more about cookies, how we use them on our site and how to change your cookie settings please click here to view our cookie policy. By continuing to use this site without changing your settings you consent to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.